The Cubs' Offseason Moves: A Strategic Masterclass or Missed Opportunities?
Welcome to BCB After Dark, the ultimate late-night hub for baseball enthusiasts, night owls, and Cubs fans worldwide. Step inside, shake off the chill, and join us for a deep dive into the Cubs' offseason maneuvers. No cover charge, just bring your thoughts and your favorite beverage—we’ve got the rest covered.
But here's where it gets controversial... Last night, we tackled the Nico Hoerner dilemma post-Alex Bregman signing. Should the Cubs trade Hoerner or extend his contract? The debate is fiery, and the stakes are high. While I’ve argued that trading Hoerner or Matt Shaw this winter would be unwise unless an irresistible offer emerges, the Giants’ interest in Hoerner has sparked speculation. Jeff Passan hinted at potential discussions, but Bruce Levine suggests the Cubs aren’t eager to part with Hoerner unless the Giants present an offer they can’t refuse. And this is the part most people miss... The Giants lack the assets to make a compelling trade without sacrificing their own core players. So, where does that leave us? 63% of you believe the Cubs should extend Hoerner and explore trading Shaw, while 26% think letting Hoerner walk after this season—with Shaw taking over in 2027—is the way to go. What’s your take? Is there a middle ground we’re overlooking?
Now, let’s shift gears to something a bit lighter—music and movies. Tonight, we’re featuring the legendary Miles Davis Quintet at their 1967 peak in Germany. Davis on trumpet, Wayne Shorter on saxophone, Herbie Hancock on piano, Ron Carter on bass, and Tony Williams on drums. Their rendition of “I Fall in Love Too Easily” is a must-listen. And don’t forget to vote in the BCB Winter Science Fiction Classic before tomorrow—it’s 2001: A Space Odyssey versus Seconds. Tomorrow’s showdown? Star Wars against Alien. Talk about heavyweights!
Back to the Cubs... Barring any unexpected trades involving Shaw or Hoerner, the Cubs’ major offseason moves likely concluded with the Bregman signing. We might see a few waiver claims (like Justin Dean) or minor league deals, but don’t hold your breath for another blockbuster. Let’s recap their key moves:
IN:
1. Phil Maton (RHP) – 2 years, $14.5M
2. Hoby Milner (LHP) – 1 year, $3.25M
3. Caleb Thielbar (LHP) – Re-signed, 1 year, $2.75M
4. Tyler Austin (1B) – 1 year, $1.25M
5. Jacob Webb (RHP) – 1 year, $1.5M
6. Hunter Harvey (RHP) – 1 year, $6M
7. Edward Cabrera (RHP) – Trade with Marlins
8. Alex Bregman (3B) – 5 years, $175M
OUT:
- Free Agency Losses: Reese McGuire, Eli Morgan, Willi Castro, Drew Pomeranz, Michael Soroka, Ryan Brasier, Taylor Rogers, Brad Keller, Carlos Santana, Kyle Tucker, Justin Turner
- Trades: Andrew Kittredge to Orioles (cash), Owen Caissie, Cristian Hernandez, Edgardo De Leon to Marlins (for Cabrera)
Now, the million-dollar question: How would you grade the Cubs’ offseason? A bold success, a cautious strategy, or a missed opportunity? Let’s hear your thoughts in the comments. And remember, if the Cubs pull off a surprise move, we’ll revisit this discussion.
Thanks for joining us tonight. Stay warm, recycle those cans, tip your waitstaff, and join us again tomorrow for more BCB After Dark. Until then, keep the conversation going!
